herald
Click above to learn more.
(Another different Herald)
Our French
DeWitt Lineage
for John DeWitt?
 
A 227 year Lineage of Our DeWitts

(from John Dewitt (born Abt 1758) to Joel Swanger DeWitt, Sr (died 1987))

v. 4: 
10/14/09
by Don DeWitt (contact)
herald
Click above to learn more.
(Another
different Herald)


.
.
Frenchflag
France
R
PA flag
Pennsylvania
Introduction
.
sitemap
.
VA flag
Virginia
.
WV flag
West Virginia
R
MO flag
Missouri
.
Did you know ... that DeWitt is the 1,446th most popular last name (surname)
in the United States with a frequency of 0.009%?





































The Beginning

As I begin to create this website in April 2009, I have a feeling that we are finally heading in the right direction.  Ever since I first viewed Roots on TV in the 1970s, I have been infected with the genealogy bug.  Now 30+ years later, I am accepting of the idea which was first suggested when I started snooping around in the family files, that we are of French descent.  Indeed, when I rifle my files to find the first typed listing of family connections, I find that the first paragraph claims a French connection to we DeWitts.

As soon as I began searching, everything I encountered with regards to DeWitts was Dutch, Dutch and more Dutch!  So.. surely my ancestors must have been in error!  How could a family centered in the great state of Missouri, without access to the internet, know from where our family traveled?  There did not seem to be any family bibles or anything else that could be trustworthy. Just a two-page typed document written by some relative back in the 1930s.  I did not even know the author.  But I did have access to hundreds of family photos from both grandparents which included photos back into the late 1800s!  All of those strangers!  I wanted to get to know them.


DISCUSSIONS MENU

First DeWitt
Clan:
Kingston, NY

Second DeWitt
Clan:
Long Island, NY
Third DeWitt
Clan:
Virginia
Fourth DeWitt
Clan:
France
New
Cousins


Conclusions


(also My DNA)






Return to Top

The First DeWitt Clan


And so it went for the next 29 years... we are Dutch!   We just need to figure out all of the connections.  After all, those Dutch families that arrived in the Kingston, New York area or a later discovered Long Island DeWitt clan in the 1600s all came from the Netherlands.  And they all had huge families from which we MUST have descended. 

In my initial investigations I traced our family back to Thomas Dewitt in Virginia (now West Virginia) and could not find out any information as to the identity of his parents. So one spring back in 1981 my wife and I headed down to West Virginia because we saw in a road atlas Buffington's Island in the Ohio River near Ravenswood WV, and we figured there had to be an important story there since we knew that Thomas Dewitt had been married to Mary Magdalene Buffington.  Once we arrived we found the genealogical section of the Jackson County WV Public Libraryin Ravenswood, WV and we had a field day reading Jackson County history books and the census records.  We even found the DeWitt Cemetery where Thomas and family members were buried. It was then that I discovered that John Dewitt was Thomas's father and that he had married Nancy Culbertson.  And then I pondered for the first time: "Who was John's father?"

The next day at the library, I noticed a nicely bound family genealogy entitled  Rowley-King and Allied Families, by Homer King Rowley and Ruth McCammon Rowley which had recently been published in 1980.  I walked by the shelf and pulled it out because it was so handsomly bound and I wondered how one goes about publishing a genealogy.  I was floored when I found a chapter on the DeWitts, the Culbertsons and the Buffingtons!  (Homer was a descendant of John Dewitt too through John's daughter Martha Charlotte Dewitt who married John W. Rardin.)
 
I was amazed!  This was my first "genealogical dream come true day." Surely, the information was the truth!  After all, it was a published book! (I had just finished writing my PhD thesis and was quite convinced that all books are thoroughly evaluated before the information was published!) In their book, they too claimed that we descended from the Kington, New York Dutch DeWitts! To their credit, they admitted no proof, but it made for a great story, and as a beginner, why not believe those who had toiled so hard in the creation of their 200+ page book?  It was such a handsome book!  I corresponded with Ruth soon afterward just after Homer's death. She sold me a copy of the genealogy and provided quite a bit of additional information.  To this day, I thank them for their efforts.

But it seems to be that their hunch about a connection to the Kingston Dewitts was wrong too!

When I started publishing my website about the DeWitts, my first site was all about how we might have descended from the Tjerck Dewitt family of Kingston, New York. (Kingston)  So much information was available.  It looked so good.  But I just could not connect our John DeWitt (1758-1820) to any of those descendants.  Of course, the census data was not available for that time in our history before 1790, so I just accepted that "someday" we would find the right piece of information.  Certainly, the internet would bring that to us soon!  Ha ha!


Return to Top

The Second DeWitt Clan


Along the way, I met some others curious about our line, and it was suggested that maybe we descend from the OTHER New York DeWitts.  I had not even heard of another clan! I smiled!  Finally! The Long Island clan must surely be ours!  We were still Dutch... just different Dutch right? This time, we found an Ezekiel Dewitt living near Pittsburgh at the same time that our John Dewitt lived in the region around 1790.  But we just could not find the proof that Ezekiel was our John's father!  He did have a son named John but that John married another woman! (Catherine Quick was her name.  Not Nancy Culbertson.)  In that process, I published our second Wishful Thinking family line back to the 1600s in New York with the Jan Dewitt family. (Long Island)


Return to Top

The Third DeWitt Clan


And then along came the genetic revolution in the 2000s and with it, cheap DNA analysis of the Y chromosome!  In 2008 I joined the FamilyTree DNA project with the hopes that I would finally connect with another DeWitt whose ancestry was better established. In that process I learned of several other Dewitt clans including a clan originating in the Virginia area. And some of those descendants also believed that they American ancestor was French!  After realizing that the Dewitts of American are not just Dutch descendants and recalling that my family papers had claimed French descent, I gathered up some cheek cells and sent them off to be analyzed for sequences of bases found on my Y chromosome. 

The results started to come back to me in pieces and to my great surprise and elation, my first set of 12 genetic markers matched exactly with those participants who claimed Virginian DeWitt connection!  "Just call me Frenchy", I exclaimed!  "My family was right after all!", I thought!

And then the next 25 markers results arrived.

What the heck is a marker?
A marker represents the number of copies of short sequences of DNA found in specific locations on my Y-chromosome.  A person's result is a number such as 19 which means that there are 19 sets of that sequence on my chromosome.  Since Y-chromosomes are passed from father to son, someone with whom I share an ancestory, should have basically the same number for each marker.  If you examine many markers, the values become a unique fingerprint to closely related males.  So having 12 markers with exactly the same values as someone else would suggest that we are closely related! However there are billions of people on this planet and others may share the same values by chance.  So the best thing to do is look at more markers!
Which I did.  (If you want to learn more: DNA 101)

Sadly, once I compared 37 sets of markers to my new cousins in the Virginia clan I found many differences.  In fact.. so many that it is said that I do not share a common ancestor with them within 500 years!

Sigh.

Oh... I did not match members of either of the New York Dutch Dewitt clans either!!!!

Here is the project site if you are interested:
http://www.familytreedna.com/public/dewittfamilydna/default.aspx



Up to this time, three 1600s Dewitt clans have been claimed.
a. Tjerck Dewitt from the Kingston NY area
b. Jan Dewitt from the Long Island, NY area
c. Jacob Dewitt from the Virginia area

As of July 2009, my DNA did not match (at the 37 marker analysis level) with ANY members in the DeWitt DNA group.  There are currently 20 other members.

This means that one or more of the following may be true:
a. There is a fourth Dewitt clan from whom our John Dewitt descends.
b. There was an adoption in my line somewhere back in time. (So I would not really be a DeWitt. I know I am not adopted.)
c. There was an illegitimate birth somwhere back in time. (So I would not really be a DeWitt.)
d. There were these "nonpaternal events (b. & c.)" in the history of the OTHER DeWitt DNA member's lines.
     (And so.. they are NOT REALLY DeWitts! hah!)

In case b. or c., this issue may affect only my line from Thomas DeWitt (1791-1879), so I need to find other male DeWitts other than my brother! So far... I have not found any!

In cases a. and d., we need more DNA to further evaluate.

No matter what, we need more male Dewitt DNA!
Please contact me if you can advise or help.

But this is not the end of the story....



Return to Top

The Fourth DeWitt Clan


With the new realization that we need more DNA, I have been searching for living John DeWitt descendants with the hopes of gathering new information and maybe some more DNA volunteers!

In that effort, I made acquaintance with Terry Meehan who descends from what I call the California DeWitts in our clan, whose ancestors moved out west in the 1880s from Missouri.  Her family descends from Thomas Buffington DeWitt who was a son of Thomas DeWitt who was a son of our John DeWitt. My line descends from Thomas B's brother Joel DeWitt. I have never known any of them until now. Not only was it nice to meet a new cousin, but she had a treasure trove of photos and references that I had never seen!  Talk about a genealogists sweet day dream!



HISTORY OF

FRESNO COUNTY

CALIFORNIA

WITH

Biographical Sketches

OF

The Leading Men and Women of the County Who have

been Identified with its Growth and

Development from the Early

Days to the Present. 

 

History by

Paul E Vandor 

 

Illustrated

Complete in Two Volumes

 

Historic Record Company

Los Angeles, California

1919

 

On page 911-912 was written a story about MADLAIN (McCullough) DeWITT.  It is a four paragraph story.  I have included a transcription below because it mentions without naming, him, John DeWitt in paragraph 3.  The importance is that this document claims that this ancestor was born in France.

 

 

------Paragraph 1------

 

“MADLAIN DeWITT. --- A distinguished lady of Selma, the descendant of noted American Forebears, and highly esteemed in the town where she is best known as the widow of a very worthy citizen, Mrs. Madlain DeWitt enjoys a wide circle of friends. She was born in Sullivan Coutny, Mo., and is a daughter of John McCullough who married Elizabeth Bell, a native of Pittsburgh, the ceremony taking place in Pennsylvania.  He had been born in Ohio, went South to Louisiana, then North again and West to Missouri, where in Sullivan County he develped a farm; and when the Civil War broke out, he enlisted in the Union Army, served with the Twenty-third Missouri Volunteers, and was made a major.  Eight children were born to these devoted parents, among whom our subject was the fifth and the oldest girl.

 

------Paragraph 2------

 

She grew up in Sullivan County, attended the common schools, and when twenty-one years of age was there married to Thomas Buffington DeWitt, a native of Virginia who served in the Home Guards at Milan, Mo. He was a farmer and stock-raiser at first in Adair County, that state, in 1872, and in 1884 came to Fresno County, where they settled on a ranch four miles north of Selma, on what was known as the Russell Quarter.  They had ten children, of whom the second daughter, Luella E., now Mrs. Garnet Adkins of Los Angeles, was married in Missouri, and the seventh child, a little girl named Alta, died there; so that they brought with them to California eight children, namely: Mary Elizabeth, who is Mrs. W. H. Say; William Henry, the blacksmith at Caruthers; Oscar, a well-borere at Selma; Florence, the wife of W. J. Boles of Fresno, a rancher near Caruthers; Viola, wife of R. M. Pettus, a housepainter in Oakland; Shearon, an engineer at Sacramento; and Thomas Buffington, at Selma.

 

------Paragraph 3------

 

This son, Thomas Buffington, recalls Mrs. DeWitt’s husband, who was born at Wheeling, Va., in 1833, the son of Thomas DeWitt, a Virginia farmer, whose estate near Wheeling is still owned by a member of the DeWitt family.  His father, in turn, was born in France, became a soldier in the French Army, and came to America with Lafayette, to aid in the great struggle for American Independence.

 

------Paragraph 4------

 

Mrs. DeWitt is an active member of the Presbyterian Church and there, as well as in such circles as the Red Cross, works for the betterment of society.  Her duaghter, Mrs. W. H. Say, is a well-known club-woman, and was president of the Woman’s Improvement Club at Selma for five consecutive years, an organization that has accomplished much for that beautiful town.  Upon leaving that office she turned over $1,200 in cash, which had been raised during her incumbency, and was in turn presented with a beautiful hand-painted jardiniere, by the club, in appreciation of her vauled services.”

-------END-------

 



Thank you Terry Meehan for this resource!


If anyone has access to information about Lafayette that verifies this 1919 claim about our DeWitt ancestor, please contact me. 


La
fayette’s first ship was called the Victory (a.k.a., "La Victoire") and they arrived from France in 1777 in South Carolina followed by a 700 mile trip up to Philadelphia. (The Trip) Several men accompanied him.  We need to determine if a DeWitt came with him.  Hopefully, it was our John DeWitt.

An alternative is that our John arrived with Lafayette in his second arrival in his French frigate (the "L'Hermoine") on March 19th, 1780 at the port of Boston.


Actually, it may never be known:  The Ships




ANOTHER CLAN WHO DESCENDS FROM A LAFAYETTE CREWMATE?

With this new information, we also enter the world of Me Too!

Yes... there is another Dewitt family who claims THEIR ancestor floated over with Lafayette!
Meet James H. DeWitt, born 1744 in Bordeaux, France:  (Another crewmate)
I have written to the author of this genealogy without response.
They also admit that they have no proof and the idea simply comes from family history!

It would be very interesting to compare Y chromsome DNA with someone in that family!

Perhaps their James and our John were brothers?




Speaking of related clans......

Return to Top

NEW COUSINS


In the summer of 2009, I was contacted by Bernie DeWitt who had contacted the DeWitt DNA project leader, Floyd DeWitt.  He had a DNA analysis from another company and wanted to see how his compared to theirs (including mine.)   Yep.... 22 of his first 23 markers matched my first 22 leaving only 1 mismatch! 

However, having learned the cruel realities of DNA analysis and comparison with others with just a few data markers, Floyd and I urged Bernie to join us and get his DNA analyzed to the 67 marker level which I had already done.

Finally, in early October 2009, his data arrived, and we match exactly when 66 markers are compared, and we are only different by 1 value on the other marker!

What does that mean?

If one includes the fact that Bernie and I do not share a common ancestor back at least to the 1750s (6 generations), there is a 75% chance that he and I share a common ancestor within 9 generations, and a 90% chance that we have a common ancestor by 11 generations back.

The Related DeWitt clans:
Don DeWitt  <----DNA Match---->  Bernie DeWitt

Joel S. DeWitt, Jr (living)

Joel S. DeWitt, Sr (1893-1987)
Royce J. DeWitt (1912-1987)
Mark P. DeWitt (1858-1937) William I. DeWitt (1875-1925)
Joel DeWitt (1816-1890) John P. DeWitt (1833-1917)
Thomas DeWitt (1789-1879) Larkin DeWitt (1794-1873)
John DeWitt (1759-1820)
Benjamin DeWitt (17??-1802)

Benjamin lived in Massachusetts and New York.
John lived in Pennsylvania and West Virginia.

The big question:

Were John and Benjamin brothers or cousins?

The DNA match between Don and Bernie with only 1 out of 67 mismatches, suggests that John and Benjamin are more likely to be cousins rather than brothers. 

Hopefully we can find more male DeWitts who descend from each clan to add to the strong data that suggest we have a common ancestor.


And now for the realllllly interesting information:
.
.
.

Bernie's family history goes only back to Larkin.  Others have suggested Larkin's father was Benjamin. 

Also.... those other histories suggest that Benjamin was the son of Isaiah Witt (1726-????) rather than a DeWitt! 

They also claim that Isaiah's father was Thomas Witt (1696-1739) who was the son of John Witt
(1651-????), who was the son of John Witt (1612-1672), who was the son of Jacob Witt (1586 in France-????).  (See link below for their data, and a new summary table below the URL.)

http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~kelliesconnections/Descendants%20of%20Jacob%20Witt.html

Don DeWitt  <----DNA Match---->  Bernie DeWitt

Joel S. DeWitt, Jr (living)

Joel S. DeWitt, Sr (1893-1987)
Royce J. DeWitt (1912-1987)
Mark P. DeWitt (1858-1937) William I. DeWitt (1875-1925)
Joel DeWitt (1816-1890) John P. DeWitt (1833-1917)
Thomas DeWitt (1789-1879) Larkin DeWitt (1794-1873)
John DeWitt (1759-1820)
Benjamin DeWitt (17??-1802)

Isaiah Witt (1726-????)

Thomas Witt (1696-1739)

John Witt (1651-????)

John Witt (1612-1672)

Jacob Witt (1586 in France-????)


I am trying to contact those who claim this and see if we can come up with any verification.


Certainly the John and Thomas names in the Witt line match our first names.

It is an interesting idea.

In case you are wondering if Benjamin could be John DeWitt's (1759-1820) brother:
Benjamin's claimed siblings were:

Children of ISAIAH WITT and DEBORAH STEWART are:
                   i.    ASA WITT, b. Abt 1752 d. Unknown. 
                  ii.    MARTHA WITT, b. 06 Aug 1748, Marlborough, Middlesex, MA;
                                                          d. 13 Aug 1750, Marlborough, Middlesex, MA.
                 iii.    ARTEMUS WITT, b. 13 Aug 1750, Marlborough, Middlesex, MA; d. 26 Apr 1823.
                  iv.   BENJAMIN DEWITT, b. 06 Jun 1754, Fitchburg, MA; d. Abt. 1802, Fairfield, Herkimer, NY.
                  v.    PERSIS WITT, b. 1755, Fitchburg, Worcestor, MA; d. Unknown.
                 vi.    MOSES WITT, b. 31 Jul 1759, Fitchburg, Worcestor, MA; d. 15 Dec 1850, Lowville, Lewis, NY.
                vii.    LEVI WITT, b. 1769, Fitchburg, Worcestor, MA; d. Unknown.



Return to Top


Conclusions


So there you have it.  This is where we stand in October 2009!
The research can be summarized as:


Assuming no adoptions or hanky panky in the family lines, and that my DNA represents John Dewitt's,
1. We are not members of the two Dutch New York clans.
2. We are not members of the Virginia clan
3. We are a fourth clan, among others.
4. We may be of French descent.
5. We have discovered a related DeWitt clan who shares a common ancestor within 300-400 years.

Further progress will probably require more DNA testing.
It would be really interesting to find a DNA match with a Witt descendant wouldn't it?

Please contact me if:
1. you have other ideas.
2. if you know of a male within our clan (or Bernie's clan) who could be willing to be tested for DNA matches.
3. if you know of a male in the other crewmate DeWitt clan who could be tested.

To learn more about our John Dewitt clan:  Our Known DeWitt Ancestry.

To learn more about Bernie's Benjamin Dewitt clan: Benjamin DeWitt Ancestry.

Return to Top

DISCUSSIONS MENU

First DeWitt
Clan:
Kingston, NY

Second DeWitt
Clan:
Long Island, NY
Third DeWitt
Clan:
Virginia
Fourth DeWitt
Clan:
France
New
Cousins


Conclusions


(also My DNA)