SiteMAP

DeWitt Genealogy

John
McCullough



Elizabeth M.
Bell
version 15: 7/11/09
photos
below




(son of Charles McCulley??
b. ?, Ulster, Ireland      
d. 1821 Ross Co, OH

(See rationale below)

and


??
b. ?    
d. ?




(daughter of Thomas Bell
b. 1775 in ? 
d. 1825 in ?


and

Mary McAllister
b. 1786 in ?
d. 1834 in ?
)

JOHN INFO

b. 22 June 1809
   in PA or OH

d. 7 Oct 1863 or 1865?
    at Rolla, MO,
    of typhoid fever while serving
    as major of the 23rd Regiment,
    MO Volunteer Infantry
    during the Civil War

    He is buried in
McCullough Cem
    near Cora, MO, which is
    near Milan, Reger and Browning,
    Sullivan Co, MO (FindAGrave)

The courthouse square of Sullivan County
originally was the site of a curious V-shaped
mound, pointing to the northwest, elevated
about 15 feet at the highest point. When
leveling the mound, excavators found three
Indian skeletons. Stones which had been
placed around the skeletons were used as
foundation stones for the jail.

The second courthouse for Sullivan
County occupied the site of this mound.
Major John McCullough constructed
the building in 1857-58 at a cost of
$5,000. The cupola was added later.
This was the first brick structure in Milan.

courthouse
(ref)

Reference about early settlers:
http://sullivan.mogenweb.org/settlements.html


married
17 July 1831,
at Hiland Presbyterian
Church in Pittsburgh, PA



Meet the
children.


Additional
Info

ELIZABETH INFO

b. 19 Aug 1810
    in Pittsburgh, PA,
     but perhaps in
     Washington Co, PA

d. 30 Apr 1886
     in Sullivan Co, MO.,
    

    She is buried in
McCullough Cem
    near Cora, MO, which is
    near Milan, Reger and Browning,
    Sullivan Co, MO  
(FindAGrave)

She was living with son
Sharon in 1880 at age 70


Middle initial from 1850
census.

A Margaret Bell was the wife of Benjamin Mairs
whose children were involved with several DeWitts.
Margaret was born in 1806 in OH and was
the daughter of unknown parents. 
I have not seen any information that links
Elizabeth and Margaret
but they seem to be possible sisters.





John
From Seitz Genealogy
Also Gooch 23rd Infantry website

Eliz
From Seitz Genealogy

John McCullough
was born 22 June 1809 in Pennsylvania or Ohio. He died 7 Oct 1863, at Rolla, Mo., of typhoid fever while serving as major of the 23rd Regiment, Missouri Volunteer Infantry during Civil War. He is buried in McCullough Family Cemetery near Cora, Mo. (Near Reger, Sullivan Co, MO) John's parents are unknown (see below).

John worked as carpenter early in his life before becoming a farmer. He and his family migrated to Boonville, Cooper County, Mo. in 1836, but apparently did not come directly from Pennsylvania as a son (Sharon W.) was born in New Orleans in 1833. The family moved from Boonville to Sullivan County in 1840, making him one of county's early settlers. He is identified in late 19th century histories of Sullivan County as the architect of the first three bridges built in county in 1849 and 1850.

Along with Joel DeWitt and others, he was a leader in seeing that Sullivan County sent a pro-Union delegation to the Missouri state convention on secession, although many had initially thought the county was sympathetic to the South. John supposedly was later targeted for assassination along with some others because they were so outspoken and effective in their pro-Union views. The plot was apparently abandoned when pro-Union people caught wind of it and threatened reprisals.

John enlisted in Company A 23rd Regiment Missouri Volunteer Infantry in the of spring 1861 and was elected and commissioned major (third highest rank). He was taken prisoner in the Hornet's Nest at the battle of Shiloh (6-7 April 1862) and retained at Chattanooga, Tenn., and Macon, Ga. for six months. After his exchange for Confederate prisoners held by Union forces, he commanded the 23rd Regiment in Missouri. He was elected state senator in the fall of 1862 and held post at death (it was apparently not unusual for legislators to also be in military).  For information about the 23rd Regiment click on the sign at the right.

More about them by Karl Seitz (Ref)


Elizabeth Bell
was born in 19 Aug 1810, most likely in Pittsburgh, Penn., but perhaps in Washington County, PA.

Her parents were Thomas Bell (1775-1825) and Mary McAllister (1786-1834).

She died 30 April 1886 in Sullivan County, Mo., and is buried in McCullough Family Cemetery near Cora, Mo.

Elizabeth and John were married 7 July 1831 at Hiland Presbyterian Church in Pittsburgh by Rev. Robert Patterson.

From Seitz Genealogy

23rd
Rex Gooch's Website
John McCULLOUGH's life is well documented after the mid 1830s. My problem is in getting back another generation. The best leads relate to his wife, Elizabeth M. BELL, whose ancestory has been discovered through some joint research by myself and some cousins. But first something about John.

John was born in either Pennsylvania or Ohio 22 June 1809. The conflict in location is in successive census records, although if we are correct in our theory about his parents, the family lived close to the Pennsylvania- Ohio state line. He married Elizabeth M. BELL 17 July 1831, in Pittsburgh, Penn., according to family records. Shortly thereafter they apparently moved to New Orleans where their oldest son, Sharon W., was born 16 Aug. 1833. In 1836, the family moved to Boonesville, Mo. and then in 1840 to Sullivan County, Mo., where John was among the early settlers. John was a carpenter and a farmer. He is credited with designing and building some of the early bridges in Sullivan County.

John was also active in political life. He and his friends, including Joel DeWITT, father-in-law to a few of John's children, were instrumental in sending a pro-union delegation to the state convention that was called to have Missouri join the Confederacy. John was a major in the 23rd Missouri Volunteer Infantry during the Civil War and second in command of the unit at the Battle of Shiloh. The 23rd was an unassigned unit that was attached to Gen. Prentiss when it arrived during the first day of the battle and was among the units that held the Hornet's Nest until late in the day, preventing a Confederate victory. After surrendering with his unit, John was a POW in Macon, Ga., for six months before being exchanged. He returned to the 23rd and was serving as commanding officer when he died of disease at Rolla. Mo. 7 Oct. 1863. At the time he was also a state senator.

There is reason to believe that John is a son of Charles McCULLEY, who was born in Ulster, Ireland. and came to Pennsylvania with his parents, Francis McCulley and Jane Bingham. However, my McCullough cousins and myself have yet to find solid proof.

Charles and his parents originally settled in Chester County, Penn., but later moved to Mercer County, Penn. Charles' land actually touched the state line with Ohio. Charles moved to Ross County, Ohio, around 1818 and died there in 1821. He does not appear to have left a will.

We can account for most of Charle's children, including a daughter, Marie, who married John Proudfoot, and some sons for whom his brother-in-law, Dr. France J. LeMoyne of Washington County, Penn., became guardian. But no document has been found saying Charles had a son named John. The change from McCulley to McCullough is not remarkable -- as best I can tell the pronunciation of the two names was once much closer than it is now.

We know from family tradition that long predates our discovery of Charles McCulley that a niece named Elizabeth PROUDFIT once visited the McCulloughs in Missouri. Until we discovered Charles McCulley, it had been assumed she was a niece of John's wife, Elizabeth BELL, now we believe she was a niece of John.

As for Elizabeth BELL, it has been discovered in "The Bell Family of Mifflin County, Pennsylvania," a 1941 book written by Raymond Martin Bell, that Elizabeth BELL's parents are Thomas BELL (1775-1825) and Mary McALLISTER (1786-1834). The Bell line can be traced back to her great-grandfather, William BELL, who apparently came to this country from Northern Ireland before 1738. Unfortunately, the now deceased Raymond M. Bell told a cousin and fellow researcher that he had not done detailed research on our branch of the Bell line, much less John McCullough.

What we do know of Elizabeth's family are her siblings names and further details about some of them. She was the second of eight children.
  • Her older brother was John B. Bell, born 1804. He married Mary McFARLAND.
  • Elizabeth was born 10 August1810, apparently in Pittsburgh. She died 30 April1886 in Sullivan County, Mo.
  • Sarah Bell married James MARSHALL.
  • William McAllister Bell was born 1813 and died 1893. He married Elizabeth Stuart McFADDEN. Based on family information that accounted for only two of Elizabeth Bell McCullough's brothers, it is assumed that William and Elizabeth S. Bell had at least two children: Emma M. Bell, who was the executor and trustee of her uncle Thompson's estate, and James M. Bell.
  • Thompson Bell was born 1815 and died 9 Sept. 1886. He never married. He was an official with the Merchants and Manufacturers' National Bank in Pittsburgh. He visited the McCulloughs in Missouri.
  • Robert Boyd Bell was born 1817 and died 5 Aug. 1870. He never married.
  • Thomas Sharon Bell was born 1820 and died 1856. He never married.
  • Mary Jane Bell was born 1824 and died 1889. She married Archibald MARSHALL. They had a daughter who married Rev. Greenley and at least one son, Marshall Bell, although no explanation of his name has been found.


Return to Top
Children of John McCullough
Issue: Sex Born Birthplace Died Deathplace Married Date Children
Children of John McCullough (b. 22 Jun 1809  d. 7 Oct 1863 Rolla, MO) 
and Elizabeth Bell (b. 19 Aug 1810  d. 30 Apr 1886)
married in 7 Jul 1831
Sharon W.

He is mentioned in the Seitz history of John and Elizabeth.

He (age 36) is also living with  his mother Elizabeth in 1870 and in 1880

In
1860, name spelled as Charon.
and he is living with parents as Sharon W in 1850 and Charon in 1860 census.

Also listed in ancestry.com
as Sharen in 1880.

M 16 Aug 1833

error in age 36 in 1880 census

Seitz history states he was born 16 Aug 1833

see also
cemetery
inscription

New Orleans,
Orleans Parish, LA
23 Jul 1899 Sullivan Co, MO

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Birth Date:
16 Aug 1833
Death Date:
23 Jul 1899

obit
Died Sharon McCullough July 23, 1899. He was born in New Orleans 1833 and moved to Sullivan Co. in 1840. (ref)

Buried:
McCullough Cem,
Sullivan Co, MO


(FindAGrave)
Not married
--
From Bible of John and Elizabeth McCullough
(from Joy Ware 7/2008)

Sharon was born in New Orleans. In 1836 was brought by his parents to Boonville, Mo. In 1840 they moved to Sullivan Co, before the Co. was laid out. He received a limited education at the neighborhood log schoolhouse.  During the early part of the Civil war he ran a heard of mules into Iowa for safe keeping from the invasion ofthe Confederate army, until the government should need them (mules).  He had 560 acres of good land, well stocked and improved. A man of integrity and high character, a public spirited citizen, and liberal contributor to all educational and laudable enterprises. Was reared by a Republican father and adhered to that party. Sharon remained a bachelor in the home with the Mother until her death April 30, 1886. He erected a Presbyterian church on edge of farm for his Scotch Mother. Sharon died July 23, 1899 from an accident in a hay field.

Elliot M 13 Dec 1834 MO 20 Sep 1843

MO - - -
Mary F 21 Feb 1836
MO
27 Feb 1836

MO - - -
Webster

He is living with parents in 1850 in 1860, and in 1870 census.

also...
son of John
because will
states he is
brother of Sharon and Warren, and Madlain
and Elizabeth



listed as
Mccullugh
in 1870 in ancestry.com

M
17 Mar 1837 MO



Served in
Co.G 23rd Inf. B. (Civil War.)
Lieutenant

26 Aug 1876 MO

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Webster Lieut McCullough
Birth Date:
17 Mar 1837
Death Date:
26 Aug 1876

Buried:
McCullough Cem,
Sullivan Co, MO



(FindAGrave)

See Will below
?

? Grant R (adopted)
[from Will below]

b. Apr 1873
d. Aft 1920

m. Clara Bradley
     b. Nov 1877
     d.
Aft 1920
children:
     Carrol (male)
       b. 1901 MO
       d.
Aft 1920

     Kenneth
       b. 1903 MO
       d.
Aft 1920

Clara's father Jay W Bradley was living with them in Tulsa, OK in 1910.  Clara's mother Mary Elizabeth Singleton died in 1903.


Grant McCullough, ..., was married to Clara Bradley at the home of her father Jay Bradley in Milan.  They later moved to Tulsa, Oklahoma where Mr. McCullough was associated with Wm. Skelly in the oil business.  He died several years ago, but his widow and one son survice and live in Tulsa, Oklahoma. (ref)

Warren N.

(See Photo 4)



(Seitz genealogy)

Two photos with his wife. (Photo)

Another when
they were in their 50s:
OLDER


He is living with parents in 1850 and in 1860 census.

Middle initial from
1850 census.

In 1880 Warren McCullough (age 40) and wife Josephine (age 30), with daughter Elfie (age 11), Annie (age 9),
Bertha (age 7) and son Gird (age2) living in Duncatn Township, Sullivan Co, PA


Living in Polk Township, Sullivan Co. MO in 1900


M
30 Jan
1839


Cooper Co, MO 13 May
1906


Sullivan Co., MO

Buried in Oakwood Cemetery, Milan, MO

(FindAGrave)
Margaret Josephine
DeWitt

b.
8 July
1849 in
Sullivan
Co., MO


d.
30 Apr
1937 in
Milan,
Sullivan Co. MO

Buried in Oakwood Cemetery, Milan, MO

(FindAGrave)


Daughter of
Joel DeWitt
and Rachel Mairs


(see photo 1
and
photo 2
and
photo 3)

Another photo of Margaret in a big group of ladies.

Two photos with her husband. (Photo 4)

Called Phebe J and was living with parents
family in 1860.

Called Josephine in 1880 census
2 July
1865
Sullivan Co, MO

as listed in
Marriage Records
of
Sullivan Co, MO
1859-1880
pg 16
Visit Warren and Josie's
website for greater detail!


Children:

John Joel
   b.
26 May 1866
      Milan, MO
  
d.
17 Mar 1868
    '68 according to
     family records

     '88 according to:
    
Son of Warren &
     Josephine
from
     Cemetery
     Inscriptions
     of Sullivan Co.,
     MO Volume 1

   He is buried in
  
McCullough Cem
    near Cora, MO, which is
    near Milan, Reger and
     Browning,
    Sullivan Co, MO


Elfie Maud  **
  b. 25 Nov 1868
     
in Sullivan Co, MO
 
d. 28 Nov 1961,
      Los Angeles, CA
 
m. Issac S Bolt
      (see photo & info)

     
14 Oct. 1885
      in Milan, MO
       (divorced by 1900)
       b. 1864 in Villisca, IA
       d. 1938

  Children are:
      -Hazeldean Bolt
       (see photo)

       
b. 9 Nov. 1886 in
            Montgomery
            Co., IA
       
d. June 1979 in
           
San Antonio,TX
       
m. Enoch Beery
            
Seitz  Jr.
             20 Aug 1907
             in Milan, MO
             Ruth
              b. 1909
              d. 1973
             Kerlin
              b. 1916
              d. 1985
        m. Nate Snyder
             in 1950s

Ann Elizabeth  *
  b. 20 Apr 1871
  d.  1944
  m. John M. Winters

 Children are:
  -  McCullough
     b. 1893
     d. ?
  -Victor D.
    b. 1896
  - John
    b. 1901
  - daughter


Bertha M.*
  b. 15 Nov 1873
  d. Aft 1904
  m. Samuel A. Faulkner
  20 Jan 1904
  no children

Webster Elmo
  b. 15 Mar 1877
  d. 8 Aug 1879
      or 16 Aug 1879
Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1


    He is buried in
   
McCullough Cem
    near Cora, MO, which is
    near Milan, Reger and
    Browning,
    Sullivan Co, MO


Gird (Grid)*
  b. 16 Sep 1878
  d. Sep 1969
 
m. Elizabeth Amber Harris

Children are:
  -  Gerdner
     b 1910
     d ?
  -  John Warren
     b 1911
     d 1916
  -  Margaret
     b 1913

     d ?

  -  Grant Elmo
     b 1915
     d 1916
  -  Elizabeth
     b 1919

     d ?

 

   * per 1880 census
      Duncan Twhshp,
      Sullivan Co. MO 
     2 Jun 1880



Also..

Eva Pearl
  b. 29 Dec 1880
  d.
6 Dec 1959 CA
  m. Robert Daly

Golda Dean
  b. 1884
  d. 1898

Clara Gail
  b. 23 Jan 1888
  d. Aft 1920
  m. Augustus Overton Harris

Children are:
  -  Augustus Overton
     b 29 Jul 1912
     d. Aft 1920
  -  Susan
     b 16 Dec 1915
    d. Aft 1920


-----------------------------

A Louisa McCullough age 19 was living with Pink L Mairs in Bowman Township, Sullivan Co, MO in 1900.  She was born Sep 1880 and was working as a servant.  I do not know who she is.  Pink Mairs lived on the same road as Webster DeWitt.,  Rachel DeWitt,
Pink DeWitt

-----------------------------

A Maggie McCullough age 21 was living with Pink L Dewitt in Bowman Township, Sullivan Co, MO in 1900.  She was born Jun 1879 and was working as a servant.  I do not know who she is.  Pink DeWitt lived on the same road as Webster DeWitt., and Rachel DeWitt,

-----------------------------


** Karl Seitz and Joy Ware are descendants of Elfie

Madlain

(photo)

In
1860
named spelled as
Madline
and Madline in 1850.

She is living with parents in 1850 and in 1860 census.

Living with Thomas and children in 1880 in Polk Township, Adair Co, MO


Living with son Thomas B
and daughter Viola
in 1910 in Selma, Fresno Co, CA

Her father was born in OH
Her mother was born in PA



F 20 Feb 1841 ? MO
6 Feb 1927  She died in Los Angeles, CA while visiting Ella Atkins.

She is buried in Mendocino Cemetary in Selma, CA)

(FindAGrave)
Thomas Buffington DeWitt

b.
27 Mar 1832 in Wheeling,
WV

d. 
21 Oct 1891 in Selma, Fresno, CA.


Madelain was the second wife of Thomas.

(photo).

(FindAGrave)
2 Jan 1862 Mary Elizabeth "Mamie" (Say) *****
  b. 30 Oct 1862 (ref) in MO
  d. 19 Sept 1949
  m. Henry Say

Luella Eddyth "Ella" (Atkins) ***
  b. 20 Mar 1864 (ref) in MO
  d. 19 Nov 1951
  m. Joseph Garnet Atkins

William Henry
  b. 20 Sep 1865 (ref) in MO
  d. 6 Aug 1925
  m. Rosie Dunham

Oscar K.
  b. 20 Mar 1867 (ref) in MO
  d. 20 Sep 1941
  m. Rosa Agnes Sohn

Florence (Culwell/
Boles)
  b. 7 Jan 1869 (ref) in MO
  d.
Aft 1930
  m1. J. J. Culwell
  m2.
John William Boles
        b. ?
        d. Bef 1930
   Widowed
   Florence Boles living
   with Thomas B & wife
   in 1930 in Selma, CA.


Viola (Pettus) ****
  b. 8 Mar 1872 (ref) in MO
  d. 20 Jun 1934
  m. Robert Milton
       Pettus
  Viola living with mother
   in Selma, Fresno Co, CA
   in 1910.


John Aldo
  b. 3 Feb 1874 (ref)
  
in Adair Co, MO
  d. Abt 1949
  m. Anna Cora McMurtrey
  John called Aldo in 1880


Alta
  b. 16 Jun 1875 (ref) in MO
  d. 22 Mar 1876

Sharon
  b. 25 Dec 1876 (ref) in MO
  d. 3 Nov 1945
  m. Frances ?

Thomas Buffington
  b. 29 Jan 1880 (ref) in MO
  d. Aft 1930
  m. Anna E. Lohan
       b. Abt 1887 in CA
  Living in Fresno, CA with
  Anna in 1920.  Listed as T.B.
  DeWitt. No Children.
  
  Living in Selma, Fresno Co,
  CA in 1930 with sister
  Florence Boles.
No Children.


Note that in 1880 census,
Nancy E was livin with them.  She was daughter from first marriage.


Comment: see his
father's website at 

Thomas Buffington, Sr.

for more details on
the entire clan.

***
Jackie Ryland is a
descendant.


****
Greg Veneklasen is a
descendant.

*****
Terry Meehan
is a descendant


Elizabeth
E.

(Both of her parents were born in PA.)

(from 1880 & 1910 census)

Sh
e is living with parents in 1850 and in 1860 census.

She is living with her husband and family in 1870, 1880, 1900, 1910 and 1920.

F ? Jun 1844

(1900 census)
Cora, Sullivan Co,
MO

10 Jan 1938

see
JC's

Obit
Oakland, Almeda Co, CA

I do not know where they are buried!  Help please?!

(FindAGrave)
(It is a virtual grave since I don't know where she is buried.)
Joseph Culbertson
DeWitt

b.
10 Feb
1845 in
WV
(from1910 census)

d. 19 Mar 1922

* see notes.

Antioch, Contra Costa Co., CA

(FindAGrave)
(It is a virtual grave since I don't know where she is buried.)


(from1910 census)
and his Obit ... see notes)


A Joseph C. Dewitt is listed as being a member of the 44th Regiment, Missouri Infantry

and the 153rd Regiment, Illinois Infantry (1 yr 1865)

(ref: ancestry.com
listing of DeWitts in Civil War)



He was living with his own family in Sullivan Co, Mo in 1870 and  1880

In his obituary, it stated:
He
moved to Kansas in 1892 and then on to California within a few years.

Maybe ... but in 1900 he and Elizabeth were living in Polk Twnshp, in Sullivan Co., MO



* see notes

Living in Contra Costa Co., CA in 1910 census.  (near Oakland, CA).

Living in Oakland, CA in 1920 census.

10 Feb
1867

as listed in
Marriage Records
of
Sullivan Co, MO
1859-1880
pg 23

Walter *
 
b. 02 Dec 1867
 
d: 28 Aug 1868
     
Son of J.C. & E.
     (McCullough Cem)

John Wallace
(known as Dr. Wallace)
  b. 26 Jun 1869 in MO
     (age 1 in 1870
      & age 11 in 1880
      census)
  d. 1 Dec 1947
      Placer, CA
  m. Nettie M Chase in CA
        (see obit)
        b.1869    
        d.? Bef 1930


      Children:
       - Melba 
              b. 5 Oct 1899 in CA
              d. 3 Dec 1942
                   Alameda, CA
              m. ? Collins
       - Donald  Chase
               b. 15 Aug 1897 in CA
               d. 16 May 1948
                Contra Costa, CA

                  m Helen Burwell
                      aft 1920

Is he Dr. J. Wallace DeWitt
who lived next door to
Joseph C in 1910 and also
the person who announced
Dr. Thomas Bryon's
death in 1904?

John & family lived in Oakland, CA in 1920.  He was a doctor.


Emery T. *
 
b. 20 Feb 1871
 
d: 27 Feb 1879
     
Son of J.C. & E
    (McCullough Cem)

Laura Mae
  b. 12 Aug 1872 Reger, MO
  d: 6 Jun 1943 Kirksville, MO
      (Death Cert.) (FindAGrave)
  m. Warren Burton Hamilton
        b 15 Jul 1869
        d.  2 Aug 1911
            
(Death Cert.)
  children:
  - Arthur D. Hamilton
    b 1 Aug 1896 MO
    d Mar 1985 Kirksville, MO
    m. Eval L. ?
    children:
       - Elizabeth Mae
       - Warren B.

  May was mentioned in
  her mother's obit in 1938
  as living in Kirksville, MO



Martha E.
  b. 13 Aug 1874
  d. 24 Mar 1955
  m Andrew W Wilson in 1907
      b 21 Jun 1873
      d 19 Apr 1949
  children:

  - William Joseph
     b maybe 1 Mar 1910 KS
     d ? Maybe 12 Nov 1944

  - Mary Elizabeth
     b 1913 KS
     d ?

  - Margaret Virginia
     b 1914 KS
     d ?

  Martha was mentioned in
  her mother's obit in 1938
  as living in Ness City, KS



Blanche C*
 
b. 1876 (per 1880 census)
       (age 4 in June 1880)
  d: 5 Aug 1880
      Dau of J.C. & E.
     (McCullough Cem)


Joel C.*
 
b. 01 Oct 1878
       (age 1 in Jun 1880)
  d: 17 Aug 1887
      Son of J.C. & E.
     (McCullough Cem)


Nora M. *
 
b. 29 Nov 1880
 
d: 02 Jan 1884
      Dau of J.C. & E.
       buried in
       (McCullough Cem)
       died from membranous coup
       Joel DeWitt, MD signed
      
Death Certificate



Eunice Virginia
  (from 1900
census)
  b. Nov 1882 in MO
  d. 1967
  m John W Grigsby
       b 1881 CA
       d Aft 1930
  children:

  - John Jack Dewitt
     b 3 Jul 1917 CA
     d 24 Aug 1981 CA




Ernest M.
  b. 4 Jun 1886
in MO
 ?  
A son was born to
    Elizabeth and Joseph
    on 30 Jun 1886
    (Birth Record)

  d. 1 Feb 1961 CA

      (Living with parents
        at age 32 in 1920
        working as a Fire
         Insurance broker.)

   
m. Julia ?
       b 1892 CA
       d Aft 1942


* I am not sure all of these
people are children of Joseph.... their parent's initials and
dates are appropriate
though.

In 1900 & 1910
census, Elizabeth said that she had given birth to 10
children of which only 5
were alive so all of these
young deaths seem accurate.


Was Joseph a Civil War
veteran?

I found a listing for a
Joseph C. Dewitt

in the 44th Missouri
Infantry at:
http://www.itd.nps.gov

/cwss/soldiers.htm

In the 1880 census
Joseph C's family is listed as:
Elizabeth F 35
John W   M 11
S???? M   F 8
Martha F 6
Blanche F 4
Joel C M 1
plus
Ellen Dewitt, Niece age 17

RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

Ofelia Watson

adopted in 1880 census
F
Abt 1868
MO
Aft 1880
? ? ? ?

  ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

Return to Top

John and Elizabeth Bell McCullough

1850 Census: Milan, Sullivan Co, MO:  (14 Oct 1850)
John
(age 40) and Elizabeth McCullough (age 40) and son Sharon W (age 16), Webster (age 13), Warren N (age 11)
Madlin (age 9), and Elizabeth (age 6)  (Note: Ancestry.com has them listed with last name of 
Mccollough.
1850

1860 Census: Milan, Sullivan Co, MO:  (11 Sep 1860)
John
(age 50) and Elizabeth McCullough (age 50) and son Sharon (age 26), Webster (age 22), Warren (age 21)
Madline (age 17), and Elizabeth (age 15)

1860

1870 Census: Pleasant Hill Township, Sullivan Co, MO:  (13 Jul 1870)
Elizabeth
McCullough (age 59) and son Sharon (age 34) and Webster (age 30) along with Nancy Dewitt (age 15)

1870

1880 Census: Duncan Township, Sullivan Co, MO:  (2 Jun 1880)
Elizabeth
McCullough (age 70) and son Sharon (age 36).
Sharon was born in New Orleans, LA on 16 Aug 1833...
so he should have been listed as age 47.

elizabeth mccullough


Interesting name, Sharon....
I have detected this name throughout the family over at least 3 generations

1. Thomas Sharon Bell was born 1820 and died 1856.  He was the brother of John and Elizabeth Bell McCullough.
2. Sharon W. McCullough was born 1833 and died 1899. He was the son of
John and Elizabeth Bell McCullough.
3.
Sharon DeWitt was born 1876 and died 1945. He was the son of  Thomas DeWitt and Elizabeth McCullough, dau of  John and Elizabeth Bell McCullough.
4. Sharon McCullough was born 1869, son of John and Rachel McCullough.  I do not know how these McCulloughs are related but they also lived in Sullivan Co, Mo and must have known John and Elizabeth McCullough.


Return to Top

Webster McCullough
(brother of Warren McCullough)
Name: Webster Lieut McCullough
Birth Date: 17 Mar 1837
Death Date: 26 Aug 1876
Co.G 23rd Inf. B. (Civil War.)
WILL written: 9 Jul 1876 and recorded: 11 September 1876: by Warren McCullough
Will Records of Sullivan County, Missouri 1849-1880
Will Records of Sullivan County, Mo Book A
To my mother, Elizabeth, $25. To my brothers, Sharon, $25. and Warren McCullough and my adopted son Grant the remainder of my estate To my sisters: Madeline Dewitt, $25. and Elizabeth Dewitt, $1000. I give and bequeath enough of my estate to put a good fence around my fathers graveyard including expense of same. Foundations to be of brick or stone with fencing on top. I give and bequeath enough of my estate to build a good church at the cross roads school house in Pleasant Hill Township Church to be frame and called the Presbyterian Church though all other denominations to have free access to the house Say the house to cost near $2000. Warren McCullough, Adm. Written 9 July 1876 Witnesses: James W. Baxter and William H. Tharp Recorded: 11 September 1876


Return to Top

Warren McCullough and Margaret Josephine DeWitt

wm wm mDm mDm
Warren McCullough
(from Seitz genealogy)
(FindAGrave)

Margaret Josephine DeWitt McCullough
(from Seitz genealogy)
(FindAGrave)

He was born 30 Jan. 1839 in Boonville, Cooper County, Mo. He died 13 May 1906 in Sullivan County, Mo., and is buried Oakwood (aka Milan Cemetery) in Milan, Sullivan County, Mo.

His parents were John and Elizabeth (Bell) McCullough.

In the Civil War, he was a member of the 66th Regiment Missouri Militia, serving as first lieutenant (commissioned 30 Aug. 1862) of Company I and afterward as captain of Company B. At least one source says he was present but not a participant in the battle of Shiloh, at which his father was taken prisoner, but I suspect this may have been his brother Webster.

In 1876, Warren was one of three men who formed private bank at Milan, which did business until 1884 when it became First National Bank. He was involved in various businesses, most notably owner of hardware store. A Republican, he was elected Sullivan County sheriff in 1864 and re-elected 1866, serving a total of four years. He later served one-year terms as alderman from Milan's Second Ward in 1882, 1884 and 1886 and as city clerk in 1887.
She was born 8 July 1849 in Sullivan County, Mo., and died 30 April 1937 in Quincy, Ill., while visiting her daughter, Annie Winters. She is buried in Oakwood (aka Milan Cemetery) in Milan, Sullivan County, Mo.

Her parents were Joel and Rachael Ann (Mairs) DeWitt. She was known as Josephine or Josie her entire life. Josephine married Warren McCullough on 2 July 1865, in Milan and they had nine children. In 1887, she served as head of committee on scientific instructions in the schools for the Women's Christian Temperance Union, an organization in which she was long active. Josephine and Warren also frequently took in and raised children other than their own.

Other photos: photo 1 and photo 2

Another photo of Margaret in a big group of ladies.

Photos of Warren and Margaret when they were in their 50s are shown below.


Return to Top

1870 Census: Milan City, Pleasant Hill Township, Sullivan Co, MO:  (6 Jul 1870)
Warren McCullough (age 31) and wife Margaret J. (age 20), with daughter Elfie (age 1)
1870

Return to Top

1880 Census: Duncan Township, Sullivan Co, MO:  (2 Jun 1880)
Warren McCullough (age 40) and wife Josephine (age 30), with daughter Elfie (age 11), Annie (age 9),
Bertha (age 7) and son Gird (age2)
and nephew Joseph Hubbard (soon to be husband of
Alda Gertrude Thomas (dau of Mary Magdalene DeWitt Thomas who is Josephine's older sister.))
Note that Alda lives next door at the home of her mother Margaret Thomas!  Looks like a romance to me!
Alda and Joseph were married sometime in 1880 but apparently after June 2nd!
1880

Return to Top

1900 Census: Polk Township, Sullivan Co, MO:  (18 Jun 1900)
Warren McCullough (age 40) and wife Margaret J.(osephine) (born July 1849) and daughter Bertha (age 26, born Nov 1873), and son ? (splotch) (born Aug 1880)
1900

Return to Top
Warren
Margaret
Warren McCullough
Margaret McCullough
from the collection of Joel S DeWitt


Return to Top

Madelain McCullough DeWitt (website)


Return to top
Joseph Culbertson and Elizabeth McCullough DeWitt

1870 Census: Milan City, Duncan Township, Sullivan Co, MO:  (29 Jul 1870)
Joseph C. DeWitt (age 25) and wife Elizabeth (McCullough) (age 25), with son John W(allace) (age 1)
1870

Return to top

1880 Census: Polk Township, Sullivan Co, MO:  (14 Jun 1880)
Joseph Culbertson DeWitt (age 35) and wife Elizabeth (McCullough) (age 35), with son John W(allace) (age 11),
daughter S????a M (age 8), daughter  Martha (age 6), daughter Blanche (age 4), and son Joel C (age 1), and
niece Ellen Dewitt (age 17). [I can not figure out whose daughter she is but she may be using a middle name which
I have not seen anywhere.... She would have been born about 1863 and her father was born in
Va while her mother was born in MO.]---- She COULD be
Luella Eddyth "Ella" Dewitt (born 1864) who is the daughter
of Thomas Buffington DeWitt (born in VA) and Elizabeth McCullough (born in MO) who is Joseph Culbertson's father's
(Joel DeWitt) brother.  so  Thomas would be Joseph's uncle.. so she would be a great niece.?? whew!]

1880

Return to top

1910 Census: Antioch City, 8th-Twp, Contra Costa, California:  (30 Apr 1910)
Joseph Culbertson DeWitt and wife Elizabeth (McCullough) , with daughter Eunice and son Ernest.
(It is not clear who the second DeWitt family is. Is it Dr. J. Wallace DeWitt? He was born in WV in 1871.
However, Dr. J. Wallace is mentioned in Thomas Bryon DeWitt's obituary and is listed as a nephew... see above)
Actually... J. Wallace Dewitt, may be John W. Dewitt, son of Joseph.  That would make sense.  He would also
be a nephew of Thomas Bryon DeWitt.

1910 Joseph C Dewitt


Return to top
1920 Census: Precinct 8, Oakland, Alameda Co., California:  (8 Jan 1920)
Joseph C DeWitt and wife Elizabeth, with son Ernest M.jc

OBIT 1: (Joseph Culbertson  DeWitt)
Milan Republican Thurs 23 Mar 1922   (Joseph Culbertson DeWitt)
J.C. DeWitt ... Sullivan Co... Died in CA
Mrs. Josie McCullough of this city is in receipt of a message announcing the death of their brother,
J.C. DeWitt, who died at his home in Oakland, CA Mar  19, 1922...

Mr. DeWitt sold his farm and moved to Kansas in 1892, where he resided for  two or three years,
moving from there to California.  He was a brother of  W.H.W. and J.P. DeWitt, both residing near Reger...

The fact that Elizabeth is not mentioned suggests she preceeded Joseph in death which means before 19 Mar 1922


Return to Top

CONFUSIONS...

Who is John McCullough, born about 1826 in VA?

They had two children named Sharon and Warren. 
This suggests they are related in some way to our John McCullough
who also had two children named Sharon and Warren.

John and Rachel McCullough

I can't find them 1860

1870 Census: Milan Post Office, Bowman Township, Sullivan Co, MO:  (10 Aug 1870)
She (age 40) is living with John (age 44) (who was also labelled as insane) with sons George (19), James (15), Beaufort (6), Franklin (4), and Sharon (1)
John is no longer living with them.  Was he dead?

1870

1880 Census: Bowman Township, Sullivan Co, MO:  (19 Jun 1880)
She (age 49) is living alone with sons James (25), Beaufort (15), Frank (12), Sharon (10), and Warren (7)
John is no longer living with them.  Was he dead?

R

1910
In 1910, Sharon McCullough (born about 1870) lived with his wife Vadis? in Trenton Township, Grundy Co. MO.
They were married about 1899 and had no children.

1920
Buford McCullough (born about 1869 in OH) lived with his wife Liddy M in Bucklin,
and stepdaughter Rubly L Mathews in Linn Co, MO

1930
Buford McCullough (born about 1870 in OH) lived with his wife Liddy (born about 1879 inMO) in Marceline,
in Linn Co, MO




Return to Top
Cemetery Inscriptions (from ancestry.com... found by a search for Sharon.)
(Entries with color backgrounds... I figured out who they were.)


Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 3

Name: Annie McCullough
--daughter of Warren (maybe)
Birth Date: 1871
Death Date: 1944

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 3

Name: Golda McCullough --daughter of Warren
Birth Date: 1884
Death Date: 1898

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 3

Name: Helen McCullough
Birth Date: 1893
Death Date: 1894

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 3

Name: Josephine McCullough
Birth Date: 1849
Death Date: 1937

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 3

Name: Warren McCullough
Birth Date: 1837
Death Date: 1906

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume IV

Name: Marcia Ellen McCullough
Birth Date: 1932
Death Date: 1934

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Eliza E. McCullough
Death Date: 20 Jan 1949
Age: 69 yr., 1 mo.,
Wife of John McCullough

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: John McCullough
Death Date: 1945
Age: 71 years, 2 days.

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Margaret E. McCullough
Birth Date: 1847
Death Date: 1934
(Wife of Wm. McCullough )

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Opal B. McCullough
Birth Date: 16 Jul 1900
Death Date: 05 Jan 1904
Dau. of J.F. & E.E.McCullough

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Paulleen McCullough
Death Date: 07 Nov 1907
dau. of J.F. & E.E.McCullough .

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Willithe P. McCullough
Birth Date: 13 Jan 1905
Death Date: 25 Feb 1907
dau of JF. & EE. McCullough

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Wm. McCullough
Birth Date: 1840
Death Date: 1916

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Grant Elmo McCullough
Birth Date: 03 Feb 1915
Death Date: 07 Jul 1916

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: John Warren McCullough
Birth Date: 12 May 1911
Death Date: 16 Nov 1916

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Ruth Hinahaw McCullough
Birth Date: 1909
Death Date: 1945

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Thomas W. McCullough
Death Date: 1945

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Sharon McCullough
Birth Date: 16 Aug 1833
Death Date: 23 Jul 1899

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Webster Lieut McCullough
Birth Date: 17 Mar 1837
Death Date: 26 Aug 1876
Co.G 23rd Inf. B. (Civil War.)

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Maj. John McCullough
Birth Date: 22 Jun 1809
Death Date: 07 Oct 1863
in 23rd Mo. Inf.

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Elizabeth McCullough
Birth Date: 19 Aug 1810
Death Date: 30 Apr 1886
Wife of John

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Elliott McCullough
Birth Date: 13 Dec 1834
Death Date: 20 Sep 1843

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Nancy McCullough
Birth Date: 16 Apr 1853
Death Date: 01 May 1853

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Virginia McCullough
Birth Date: 02 Jun 1850
Death Date: 28 Sep 1856

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: John Joel McCullough - son of Warren
Birth Date: 26 May 1866
Death Date: 17 Mar 1888

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Webster Elmo McCullough
- son of Warren
Birth Date: 15 Mar 1876
Death Date: 16 Aug 1879

Cemetery Inscriptions of Sullivan County, Missouri Volume 1

Name: Fannie D. McCullough
Birth Date: 03 Jun 1891
Death Date: 01 Oct 1910
Wife of W.F.McCullough


Return to Top